Phage infection mediates inhibition of bystander bacteria

Anushila Chatterjee, Julia L. E. Willett, Gary M. Dunny, Breck A. Duerkop

Preprint posted on May 11, 2020

Phage treatment of E. faecalis has detrimental effects upon bystander bacteria, caused by phage induced E. faecalis T7SS expression.

Selected by Josie Gibson

Categories: microbiology


Enterococcus faecalis is a commensal of the gastrointestinal tract, but is also frequently observed in nosocomial infections. Antimicrobial resistance has been gained by E. faecalis; bacteria can survive antibiotic treatments, unlike other intestinal commensals, leading to an increased likelihood of disease. Antibiotic resistance highlights the requirement of alternative therapeutic strategies against E. faecalis infection. The use of bacteriophages (phages) are a potential therapeutic approach to target bacterial pathogens. Phages offer high specificity, often targeting a single species of bacteria. This means off-target effects caused by antibiotics, for example alterations to the rest of the microbiota, are expected to be avoided in phage treatments. However, the authors have previously discovered that phage infection of E. faecalis induces expression of type VIIb secretion system (T7SS) genes [1]. T7SSs adversely affect other bacterial species through secretion of antimicrobial molecules, suggesting that phage infections may cause indirect, and unwanted side effects on commensals. This raised an important issue, off-target effects on microbiota must be fully understood if phages are to be used therapeutically. Therefore, the effects of E. faecalis phage induced expression of T7SS genes, upon non-target (bystander) bacteria, were examined.


Key findings:

The main discovery described in this preprint is an unintentional effect on bystander bacteria when targeting E. faecalis with phage (Figure 1). Whereby phage induces E. faecalis expression of T7SS genes which reduces the viability of phage resistant Gram-positive bystander bacterial species in co-culture, including E. faecalis, E. faecium, S. aureus, L. monocytogenes. Interestingly, Streptococcal species were not affected.

Figure 1: Representation of the key findings of the study


The role of T7SS was then confirmed to cause the loss of viability on bystander bacteria. E. faecalis deficient in essB, a protein used for transport of T7SS substrates, was unable to inhibit the viability of the bystander species listed above. Furthermore, supernatant from the phage infected E. faecalis did not reduce viability of phage-resistant E. faecalis, suggesting that T7SS mediated growth inhibition is contact-dependent. The authors also identified genes that encode toxins, which likely cause the bystander species loss of viability.

Next, the authors determine the signalling pathways involved in the process. Daptomycin, an antibiotic which cause cellular membrane damage, was also shown to induce expression of T7SS genes in E. faecalis, and like phage could cause antagonistic effects to bystander bacteria. This demonstrated that cellular stress caused by phage or antibiotics induces expression of T7SS genes in E. faecalis in a similar manner. It was further found that phage treatment was better at inducing T7SS than antibiotic, and that the level of inhibition on bystander bacteria is related to the extent of T7SS expression. Finally, using E. faecalis mutants lacking proteins involved in cell envelope homeostasis or antimicrobial tolerance, IreK was found to be a key signalling pathway component in sensing membrane stress and subsequent T7SS expression.


Why I chose this Preprint:

Antimicrobial resistance is an increasingly important problem for the treatment of multiple pathogens. In addition, antibiotics lack good bacterial specificity meaning many antibiotics have unwanted side effects on commensal bacteria, which may then cause further detrimental effects. Therefore, new strategies to treat antibiotic resistant bacteria represent an extremely important research area, and an attractive possibility is phage therapy. This preprint highlights a new discovery of how off-target phage effects may occur. Understanding any off-target effects are vital for the development of future phage treatments.


Questions to the authors:

  1. The impact of antagonism was tested on multiple bystander bacterial species. Do you have a suggestion why some bacterial species, particularly Streptococcal species, do not have reduced viability since the other Gram-positive species were affected?
  2. Throughout these experiments, the VPE25 phage was used. Do you anticipate that the antagonistic effects are specific to this phage, or likely common to many phage?
  3. You demonstrate that essB is required to enable to antagonistic effects of T7SS expression. Have you tested other genes of the T7SS?
  4. The E.  faecalis strain OG1RF is used in this study. Have you tested whether the antagonistic effects are also observed using another strain, and do you plan to examine other pathogenic species which have T7SSs?


  1. Chatterjee A, Willett JLE, Nguyen UT, Monogue B, Palmer KL, Dunny GM, et al. Parallel Genomics Uncover Novel Enterococcal-Bacteriophage Interactions. MBio. 2020 Apr 28;11(2).

Tags: e. faecalis, phage, t7ss

Posted on: 31st May 2020


Read preprint (No Ratings Yet)

  • Author's response

    Anushila Chatterjee shared

    1. Functional characterization of the T7SS toxins that inhibit growth of the competitor bacteria will help us shade light on the species specificity of T7SS dependent bacterial antagonism system. Currently, we can stipulate that E. faecalis T7SS toxins specifically interacts and interferes with pathways in the bystander bacteria resulting in growth inhibition. The inherent differences between targets of E. faecalis T7SS toxins between different species potentially allows some bystander species to escape inhibition.
    2. In our previously published work, we reported that phage NPV1 infection in E. faecalis strain OG1RF leads to heightened expression of T7SS genes. NPV1 shares little genetic similarity to phage VPE25 and infects E. faecalis through a mechanism that is distinct from VPE25. Therefore, it is possible that E. faecalis T7SS is induced in response to stress during infection by diverse phages.
    3. In the current report we only tested the influence of essB on T7SS mediated bacterial competition. In the follow-up studies, we are going to investigate the contributions of other structural genes of T7SS machinery on effector molecule secretion and subsequently on interbacterial interactions.
    4. In future, we want to explore T7SS mediated antagonism with a variety of E. faecalis strains, however, finding a phage-sensitive E. faecalis strain that also carries T7SS can be challenging. Other research groups have established the role of T7SS toxins from commensal and pathogenic bacteria on competitor species [1,2]


    1. Cao Z, Casabona MG, Kneuper H, Chalmers JD, Palmer T. The type VII secretion system of Staphylococcus aureus secretes a nuclease toxin that targets competitor bacteria. Nat Microbiol. 2016 Oct 10;2:16183.
    2. Whitney JC, Peterson SB, Kim J, Pazos M, Verster AJ, Radey MC, et al. A broadly distributed toxin family mediates contact-dependent antagonism between gram-positive bacteria. Elife. 2017;6.


    Have your say

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Sign up to customise the site to your preferences and to receive alerts

    Register here