Intraspecific variation in thermal tolerance differs between tropical and temperate fishes
Preprint posted on December 07, 2020 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.12.07.414318v1.article-metrics
Fanning the flames of climate change: Tropical fish show increased sensitivity to climate warming due to their lack of intraspecific variation in thermal tolerance
Selected by Charlotte NelsonCategories: ecology, evolutionary biology, physiology, zoology
Current climate warming is changing our planet at a pace never previously recorded, and the effects of these rising temperatures are becoming increasingly well documented in many groups of animals and plants. Across the globe we are witnessing range shifts, behavioural and physiological adaptations, and phenological adjustments as species struggle to persist through these novel challenges. Whether these adaptations will prove sufficient is yet to be seen. Until now much work has been focused on whole population level responses, however the importance of intraspecific variation in relation to these changes has been somewhat overlooked. Intraspecific variation (i.e. the scope of variability between individuals of a single species) can be an important metric in how that species is able to cope with any given stressor. When a species has a broad tolerance range among its individuals, its collective sensitivity to the stressor may be reduced (figure 1). The focus of this exciting pre-print is thermal tolerance, clearly a key component of a species’ arsenal in fighting global warming.
Figure 1: Theoretical illustration showing broad (blue line) and narrow (red line) frequency distribution curves of CTmax.The curves of two species have the same mean CTmax (dashed line) but different standard deviations (S.D.). With ongoing climate change, represented by the shift in the thermal range (double-pointed arrows), individuals of the species with the narrower S.D.CTmax (red curve) are less likely to survive compared to individuals of the species with the wider S.D. CTmax (blue curve), since maximum enviromental temperatures will include values (grey area) outside their thermal tolerance range. (Lifted from Nati, et al).
Nati et al, examine the effect of intraspecific variability on thermal tolerance at a global scale. They use previously published data of critical thermal maximum (CTmax: the temperature above which a fish is unable to maintain equilibrium and will most likely die) to compare the intraspecific variation in thermal tolerance between fish species globally, covering; tropical, temperate, marine, and freshwater ecosystems.
Key findings
The key finding here is that tropical species show reduced intraspecific variation in thermal tolerance than temperate species. Considering that tropical fishes tend to exhibit a smaller overall thermal range and exist closer to their upper thermal limit than their temperate counterparts, this constraint on evolvability to rising temperatures may be another nail in the coffin for tropical species. If this reduced intraspecific variability stems from reduced phenotypic plasticity it will likely increase their sensitivity to warming most significantly in the short term. However, if it corresponds to low heritable genetic variation for thermal tolerance, the effects will be expected to persist over generational time scales. It is not clear at this point which mechanisms may be responsible for the demise of variation in thermal tolerance in tropical species, but in either case, the future does not look bright.
Figure 2: Intraspecific variation in CTmax (log10 transformed standard deviationCTmax) divided into either temperate (148 species) or tropical (55 species). (A)Separated by hemisphere, Northern (132 temperate, 33 tropical species) orSouthern (16 temperate and 22 tropical species). (B) Separated into freshwater (106temperate, 21 tropical species) and marine (42 temperate, 34 tropical species). (Lifted from Nati, et al).
Nati et al, also highlight the significant difference between freshwater and marine species, with marine species showing increased intraspecific variation compared to those from freshwater habitats. Additionally, this work suggests that species inhabiting the Southern hemisphere seem to show reduced intraspecific variability compared to those from Northern latitudes. Clearly there are various interesting aspects to this work that will be exciting avenues for future research.
Why I’m excited about this work
I think this work is really exciting because it highlights an important gap in our approach and understanding of how increasing temperatures impact species at a population level. It clearly indicates the need to include metrics for intraspecific variation in models that project the impacts of warming on fishes. This study exemplifies the importance of considering intraspecific variation when assessing tolerance to environmental stressors and is likely to be relevant to a host of different stressors, organisms, and experimental systems. I’m excited to follow this avenue of research as it progresses!
Open questions
- It is known that polar regions are warming faster than other areas of the world. Do you think this increased rate of warming may ‘even the playing field’ between temperate and tropical species in respect to thermal tolerance and adaptation?
- Why do you think that freshwater species show reduced intraspecific variation in CTmax compared to marine species? Would we not expect freshwater systems to be more thermally variable and so see a greater intraspecific variation in these groups?
- Why did you choose 23 degrees latitude as the cut off for categorising species as temperate or tropical? Surely there are differences in the variation in thermal stability between locations at any latitude – could using some measure of thermal stability be a more informative metric and do you think it would affect your conclusions?
- Southern hemisphere species seem to be acting differently to Northern hemisphere species in your dataset. Could this be a result of the extreme thermal stability caused by the Southern Ocean current?
- You mention several families (e.g. Gobiidae, Blenidae) that have species in both temperate and tropical environments. Are the overall patterns in your data reflected in these groups?
Additional references
Radchuk, V. et al, (2019). Adaptive responses of animals to climate change are most likely insufficient. Nature communications 10, 3109.
Steele, J.H., Brink, K.H., and Scott, B.E. (2019). Comparison of marine and terrestrial ecosystems: suggestions of an evolutionary perspective influenced by environmental variation. ICES Journal of Marine Science, 76 (1),50–59.
Posted on: 9th January 2021
doi: https://doi.org/10.1242/prelights.26882
Read preprintSign up to customise the site to your preferences and to receive alerts
Register hereAlso in the ecology category:
Bacteriological and histopathological findings in cetaceans that stranded in the Philippines from 2017 to 2018
Selected by | Paul Gerald L. Sanchez and Stefano Vianello |
2
Are indigenous territories and community-managed areas effective natural climate solutions? A neotropical analysis using matching methods and geographic discontinuity designs.
Selected by | Sophia Friesen |
1
Sick Bats Stay Home Alone: Social distancing during the acute phase response in Egyptian fruit bats (Rousettus aegyptiacus)
Selected by | Baheerathan Murugavel |
Also in the evolutionary biology category:
Intraspecific variation in thermal tolerance differs between tropical and temperate fishes
Selected by | Charlotte Nelson |
The Single-Celled Ancestors of Animals: A History of Hypotheses
Selected by | Hiral Shah, Dey Lab |
1
Major components in the KARRIKIN INSENSITIVE2-ligand signaling pathway are conserved in the liverwort, Marchantia polymorpha
AND
The Physcomitrium (Physcomitrella) patens PpKAI2L receptors for strigolactones and related compounds highlight MAX2 dependent and independent pathways
Selected by | Facundo Romani |
Also in the physiology category:
Intraspecific variation in thermal tolerance differs between tropical and temperate fishes
Selected by | Charlotte Nelson |
Dissecting Mammalian Spermatogenesis Using Spatial Transcriptomics
Selected by | Martin Estermann |
Sick Bats Stay Home Alone: Social distancing during the acute phase response in Egyptian fruit bats (Rousettus aegyptiacus)
Selected by | Baheerathan Murugavel |
Also in the zoology category:
Bacteriological and histopathological findings in cetaceans that stranded in the Philippines from 2017 to 2018
Selected by | Paul Gerald L. Sanchez and Stefano Vianello |
2
Intraspecific variation in thermal tolerance differs between tropical and temperate fishes
Selected by | Charlotte Nelson |
Primary sex determination in chickens depends on DMRT1 dosage, but gonadal sex does not determine secondary sexual characteristics in adult birds
Selected by | Martin Estermann |
preListsecology category:
in theFestival of Ecology! 14th to 18th December 2020 #BES2020
A list of preprints dealing with the talks/posters presented in the Festival of Ecology virtual conference held in December 2020
List by | Baheerathan Murugavel |
Bats
A list of preprints dealing with the ecology, evolution and behavior of bats
List by | Baheerathan Murugavel |
Also in the evolutionary biology category:
Festival of Ecology! 14th to 18th December 2020 #BES2020
A list of preprints dealing with the talks/posters presented in the Festival of Ecology virtual conference held in December 2020
List by | Baheerathan Murugavel |
Planar Cell Polarity – PCP
This preList contains preprints about the latest findings on Planar Cell Polarity (PCP) in various model organisms at the molecular, cellular and tissue levels.
List by | Ana Dorrego-Rivas |
TAGC 2020
Preprints recently presented at the virtual Allied Genetics Conference, April 22-26, 2020. #TAGC20
List by | Maiko Kitaoka, Madhuja Samaddar, Miguel V. Almeida, Sejal Davla, Jennifer Ann Black, Dey Lab |
ECFG15 – Fungal biology
Preprints presented at 15th European Conference on Fungal Genetics 17-20 February 2020 Rome
List by | Hiral Shah |
COVID-19 / SARS-CoV-2 preprints
List of important preprints dealing with the ongoing coronavirus outbreak. See http://covidpreprints.com for additional resources and timeline, and https://connect.biorxiv.org/relate/content/181 for full list of bioRxiv and medRxiv preprints on this topic
List by | Dey Lab, Zhang-He Goh |
1
SDB 78th Annual Meeting 2019
A curation of the preprints presented at the SDB meeting in Boston, July 26-30 2019. The preList will be updated throughout the duration of the meeting.
List by | Alex Eve |
Pattern formation during development
The aim of this preList is to integrate results about the mechanisms that govern patterning during development, from genes implicated in the processes to theoritical models of pattern formation in nature.
List by | Alexa Sadier |
Also in the physiology category:
FENS 2020
A collection of preprints presented during the virtual meeting of the Federation of European Neuroscience Societies (FENS) in 2020
List by | Ana Dorrego-Rivas |
TAGC 2020
Preprints recently presented at the virtual Allied Genetics Conference, April 22-26, 2020. #TAGC20
List by | Maiko Kitaoka, Madhuja Samaddar, Miguel V. Almeida, Sejal Davla, Jennifer Ann Black, Dey Lab |
Autophagy
Preprints on autophagy and lysosomal degradation and its role in neurodegeneration and disease. Includes molecular mechanisms, upstream signalling and regulation as well as studies on pharmaceutical interventions to upregulate the process.
List by | Sandra Malmgren Hill |
Cellular metabolism
A curated list of preprints related to cellular metabolism at Biorxiv by Pablo Ranea Robles from the Prelights community. Special interest on lipid metabolism, peroxisomes and mitochondria.
List by | Pablo Ranea Robles |