Menu

Close

Bacteriophage cooperation suppresses CRISPR-Cas3 and Cas9 immunity

Adair L Borges, Jenny Y Zhang, MaryClare Rollins, Beatriz A Osuna, Blake Wiedenheft, Joseph Bondy-Denomy

Preprint posted on March 10, 2018 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/early/2018/03/10/279141

and

Anti-CRISPR phages cooperate to overcome CRISPR-Cas immunity

Mariann Landsberger, Sylvain Gandon, Sean Meaden, Hélène Chabas, Angus Buckling, Edze R. Westra, Stineke van Houte

Preprint posted on March 08, 2018 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/early/2018/03/08/279026

Phages team up to defeat CRISPR immunity - Two new preprints investigate the role of anti-CRISPR proteins during phage infections.

Selected by Fillip Port

Background

While CRISPR-based genome engineering dominates the headlines these days, the natural function of CRISPR as a prokaryotic immune system is no less exciting. CRISPR is used by many bacteria and archea to fight off viral infections. It is a pretty effective tool and so phages had to evolve ways to suppress CRISPR immunity in order to be successful. Several phages encode proteins, so called anti-CRISPRs (Acr), which can bind to and neutralize CRISPR effector proteins in vitro. However, what role Acr proteins play in establishing phage infections in vivo is unclear. Phages infecting a CRISPR-expressing prokaryote enter a cell loaded with CRISPR effectors, which can destroy viral genomes within minutes. This raises the question whether Acr proteins, which are only expressed upon phage infection, can really act as effective immunosuppressants to protect the phage genome.

Two recent preprints now explore the role of Acr proteins during bacteriophage infections.

 

The Preprints / Key findings

The first preprint describes work by Mariann Landsberger and colleagues from Edze Westra and Stineke van Houte’s groups at the University of Exeter, while the second manuscript summarizes work by Adair Borges and others from Joseph Bondy-Denomy’s lab at UC San Francisco. Both groups started by analyzing the effect of different Acr proteins on phage infections of bacterial strains with and without CRISPR immunity. As expected, all phages successfully infected bacterial strains lacking a CRISPR immune system, while CRISPR cleared infections of phages lacking Acr genes. Interestingly, CRISPR-expressing bacteria were also protected from Acr-encoding phages added at low density and only succumbed to the infection when the viral load was high.

So why are Acr proteins an effective antidote to CRISPR at high phage density, but unable to protect phages at low density? One possibility would be that at high densities, bacteria are simultaneously infected by multiple phages and the higher load of viral genomes titrates away CRISPR effectors below a critical threshold. Borges et al. were able to exclude that hypothesis by showing that infections of an Acr phage are not helped by addition of a non-replicative phage strain that does not express an Acr proteins. Furthermore, the preprint by Landsberger and colleagues demonstrates that the critical density for successful infections by phages expressing a strong Acr protein occurs at conditions where simultaneous infections are rare. Instead, both groups propose a model where initial infections cause a immunosuppressed state that lasts long after the initial infection has been cleared. Phages that infect such immunosuppressed cells at a later stage can then successfully replicate. In support of this model, Borges et al. were able to show that transient infections of unsuccessful Acr phages can help subsequent infections to be successful. Furthermore, Landsberger et al. show that bacteria that had previously been infected with Arc phages are more susceptible to the transformation by plasmids for which they carry CRISPR spacers. In addition, both studies find that the phage density required for successful infections is inversely correlated with the affinity of the tested Arc protein for its CRISPR target protein.

Together, these data suggest that Acr proteins expressed by unsuccessful phage infections can induce an immunosuppressed state that can be exploited by subsequent phages infecting the same cell (see figure below from Borges et al.).

 

What I like about these pre-prints

The discovery and characterization of anti-CRISPR proteins has been one of the exciting developments in the CRISPR field in the past five years and has lead to a detailed biochemical and structural understanding of some Acr proteins in vitro. These two preprints now widen the focus and investigate the role of Acr proteins during phage infections. After all, as Dobzhansky famously remarked: “Nothing in biology makes sense except in the light of evolution”. With Dobzhansky’s words in mind, what I love about these preprints is that spinning the idea of an evolutionary arms race further readily gives rise to additional hypothesis that can be tested in the future (see below). If lingering Acr proteins cause immunosuppression, what mechanisms might have evolved in some prokaryotes to circumvent that? And if the currently known Acr proteins are unable to prevent elimination of the pioneer phage, what hitherto unknown mechanisms might have evolved in phages that don’t suffer this limitation? It seems certain that the golden age of CRISPR discoveries is far from over.

Besides the science, what I also like about these preprints is the fact that here two groups have investigated the same question and came up with the same answer and have decided to post their finding side-by side on a preprint server. Being afraid of being scooped ranks among the most cited reasons for scientists for being weary of posting preprints. In my view, these two preprints highlight two things: First, truly being scooped is extremely rare. That two teams independently investigating the same question would come up with an identical set of experiments is very unlikely. Rather than taking away from each other, these two manuscripts complement each other and together make a much stronger case for the conclusions than either manuscript alone would have done. Second, posting preprints gives authors control over the timepoint of when their manuscript will be publically available. This can be used to effectively coordinate the simultaneous release of complementary studies from different research teams. Maybe in the future preprint servers could offer additional tools to visibly link manuscripts reporting related findings.

 

Future directions

These preprints raise a number of questions that might be worth following up in the future.

  • Are Acr proteins on their own sufficient to cause lasting immunosuppression in bacteria? For example, would expression of a short pulse of Acr protein expressed from a heterologous plasmid be sufficient to allow subsequent phage infections at low density?
  • What is the importance of protein stability for the successful establishment of immunosuppression? Acr proteins that are more stable in the cytoplasm would be expected to provide a longer timeframe for secondary infections to occur. One prediction of that would be that prokaryotes might have evolved mechanisms to directly target Acr proteins for degradation.
  • What additional mechanisms might have evolveld in phages to circumvent elimination by CRISPR immune systems? Phages which rely on sequential infections of the same cell might have evolved ways to favor infections of immunosupressed cells. Furthermore, the relative inefficiency of Acr proteins in protecting the phage that encode them makes me wonder whether there might be other yet unidentified Acr proteins that are more potent and might be able to protect a phage that infects a cell with a fully functional CRISPR system. One might imagine enzymatic Acr proteins that can inactivate CRISPR proteins at sub-stoichiometric concentrations.

Tags: acr, crispr, phages

Posted on: 10th April 2018 , updated on: 11th April 2018

(No Ratings Yet)




  • Have your say

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Sign up to customise the site to your preferences and to receive alerts

    Register here

    Also in the evolutionary biology category:

    millepattes micropeptides are an ancient developmental switch required for embryonic patterning

    Suparna Ray, Miriam I Rosenberg, Hélène Chanut-Delalande, et al.



    Selected by Erik Clark

    Conserved phosphorylation hotspots in eukaryotic protein domain families

    Marta J Strumillo, Michaela Oplova, Cristina Vieitez, et al.



    Selected by Gautam Dey

    Peculiar features of the plastids of the colourless alga Euglena longa and photosynthetic euglenophytes unveiled by transcriptome analyses

    Kristina Zahonova, Zoltan Fussy, Erik Bircak, et al.



    Selected by Ellis O'Neill

    1

    The Ly6/uPAR protein Bouncer is necessary and sufficient for species-specific fertilization

    Sarah Herberg, Krista R Gert, Alexander Schleiffer, et al.



    Selected by James Gagnon

    Timed collinear activation of Hox genes during gastrulation controls the avian forelimb position

    Chloe Moreau, Paolo Caldarelli, Didier Rocancourt, et al.



    Selected by Wouter Masselink

    The genomic basis of colour pattern polymorphism in the harlequin ladybird

    Mathieu Gautier, Junichi Yamaguchi, Julien Foucaud, et al.



    Selected by Fillip Port

    Altering the temporal regulation of one transcription factor drives sensory trade-offs

    Ariane Ramaekers, Simon Weinberger, Annelies Claeys, et al.



    Selected by Mariana R.P. Alves

    A robust method for transfection in choanoflagellates illuminates their cell biology and the ancestry of animal septins

    David Booth, Heather Middleton, Nicole King



    Selected by Maya Emmons-Bell

    A SoxB gene acts as an anterior gap gene and regulates posterior segment addition in the spider Parasteatoda tepidariorum

    Christian L. B. Paese, Anna Schoenauer, Daniel J. Leite, et al.



    Selected by Erik Clark

    1

    Germ layer specific regulation of cell polarity and adhesion gives insight into the evolution of mesoderm.

    Miguel Salinas-Saavedra, Amber Q. Rock, Mark Q. Martindale



    Selected by ClaireS & SophieM

    1

    Wnt/β-catenin regulates an ancient signaling network during zebrafish scale development

    Andrew J Aman, Alexis N Fulbright, David M Parichy



    Selected by Andreas van Impel

    Bacteriophage cooperation suppresses CRISPR-Cas3 and Cas9 immunity

    Adair L Borges, Jenny Y Zhang, MaryClare Rollins, et al.

    AND

    Anti-CRISPR phages cooperate to overcome CRISPR-Cas immunity

    Mariann Landsberger, Sylvain Gandon, Sean Meaden, et al.



    Selected by Fillip Port

    Dynamic Kinetochore Size Regulation Promotes Microtubule Capture And Chromosome Biorientation In Mitosis

    Carlos Sacristan, Misbha Ahmad, Jenny Keller, et al.

    AND

    Self-assembly of the RZZ complex into filaments drives kinetochore expansion in the absence of microtubule attachment

    Cláudia Pereira, Rita M Reis, José B Gama, et al.



    Selected by Gautam Dey

    Individual- and population-level drivers of consistent foraging success across environments

    Lysanne Snijders, Ralf HJM Kurvers, Stefan Krause, et al.



    Selected by Rasmus Ern

    The ancestral animal genetic toolkit revealed by diverse choanoflagellate transcriptomes

    Daniel Richter, Parinaz Fozouni, Michael Eisen, et al.



    Selected by Rafael Galupa

    1

    Genome-wide selection scans integrated with association mapping reveal mechanisms of physiological adaptation across a salinity gradient in killifish

    Reid S. Brennan, Timothy M. Healy, Heather J. Bryant, et al.



    Selected by Andy Turko

    Also in the immunology category:

    Precise tuning of gene expression output levels in mammalian cells

    Yale S. Michaels, Mike B Barnkob, Hector Barbosa, et al.



    Selected by Tim Fessenden

    1

    Dynamic control of proinflammatory cytokines Il-1β and Tnf-α by macrophages is necessary for functional spinal cord regeneration in zebrafish

    Themistoklis M. Tsarouchas, Daniel Wehner, Leonardo Cavone, et al.



    Selected by Shikha Nayar

    1

    A new calcium-activated dynein adaptor protein, CRACR2a, regulates clathrin-independent endocytic traffic in T cells

    Yuxiao Wang, Walter Huynh, Taylor Skokan, et al.



    Selected by Nicola Stevenson

    Human macrophages survive and adopt activated genotypes in living zebrafish

    Colin D. Paul, Alexus Devine, Kevin Bishop, et al.



    Selected by Giuliana Clemente

    1

    Single-cell Map of Diverse Immune Phenotypes Driven by the Tumor Microenvironment

    Elham Azizi, Ambrose J. Carr, George Plitas, et al.



    Selected by Tim Fessenden

    Bacteriophage cooperation suppresses CRISPR-Cas3 and Cas9 immunity

    Adair L Borges, Jenny Y Zhang, MaryClare Rollins, et al.

    AND

    Anti-CRISPR phages cooperate to overcome CRISPR-Cas immunity

    Mariann Landsberger, Sylvain Gandon, Sean Meaden, et al.



    Selected by Fillip Port

    Galleria mellonella as an Insect Model for P. destructans, the Cause of White-Nose Syndrome in Bats

    Chapman N Beekman, Lauren Meckler, Eleanor Kim, et al.



    Selected by Heath MacMillan

    Size-dependent segregation controls macrophage phagocytosis of antibody-opsonized targets

    Matthew H Bakalar, Aaron M Joffe, Eva Schmid, et al.



    Selected by Tim Fessenden

    Also in the microbiology category:

    Agrobacterium tumefaciens divisome proteins regulate the transition from polar growth to cell division

    Matthew L Howell, Alena Aliashkevich, Kousik Sundararajan, et al.



    Selected by Hannah Behrens

    Water quality and microbial load: a double-threshold identification procedure intended for space applications

    Stefano Amalfitano, Caterina Levantesi, Laurent Garrelly, et al.



    Selected by Daphne Ng

    1

    Entomophthovirus: An insect-derived iflavirus that infects a behavior manipulating fungal pathogen of dipterans

    Maxwell C Coyle, Carolyn N Elya, Michael J Bronski, et al.



    Selected by Hiral Shah

    Soil microbial habitats in an extreme desert Mars-analogue environment

    Kimberley Warren-Rhodes, Kevin Lee, Stephen Archer, et al.



    Selected by Daphne Ng

    Ecological analyses of mycobacteria in showerhead biofilms and their relevance to human health

    Matthew Gebert, Manuel Delgado-Baquerizo, Angela Oliverio, et al.



    Selected by Hannah Behrens

    EFFECTORS OF THE SPINDLE ASSEMBLY CHECKPOINT BUT NOT THE MITOTIC EXIT NETWORK ARE CONFINED WITHIN THE NUCLEUS OF SACCHAROMYCES CEREVISIAE

    Lydia R Heasley, Jennifer G DeLuca, Steven M Markus



    Selected by Hiral Shah

    Peculiar features of the plastids of the colourless alga Euglena longa and photosynthetic euglenophytes unveiled by transcriptome analyses

    Kristina Zahonova, Zoltan Fussy, Erik Bircak, et al.



    Selected by Ellis O'Neill

    1

    Spatial Self-Organization Resolves Conflicts Between Individuality and Collective Migration

    Xiongfei Fu, Setsu Kato, Junjiajia Long, et al.



    Selected by Amanda Haage

    1

    Bacteriophage cooperation suppresses CRISPR-Cas3 and Cas9 immunity

    Adair L Borges, Jenny Y Zhang, MaryClare Rollins, et al.

    AND

    Anti-CRISPR phages cooperate to overcome CRISPR-Cas immunity

    Mariann Landsberger, Sylvain Gandon, Sean Meaden, et al.



    Selected by Fillip Port

    Mitochondrial targeting of glycolysis in a major lineage of eukaryotes.

    Carolina Río Bártulos, Matthew B. Rogers, Tom A. Williams , et al.



    Selected by Ellis O'Neill

    1

    Close