Temporal Control of Transcription by Zelda in living Drosophila embryos

Jeremy Dufourt, Antonio Trullo, Jennifer Hunter, Carola Fernandez, Jorge Lazaro, Matthieu Dejean, Lucas Morales, Katharine N Schulz, Melissa M Harrison, Ovidiu Radulescu, Cyril Favard, Mounia Lagha

Preprint posted on March 14, 2018

Measuring enhancers in motion: Quantitative live imaging coupled with modeling to study temporal control of gene expression and transcriptional memory.

Selected by Teresa Rayon

Categories: developmental biology


In this preprint, the Lagha lab studies the role of pioneer transcription factors on the temporal control gene expression. Pioneer factors are known for their ability to bind their sites when the chromatin is closed. However, how pioneer factors prime enhancers to control the time of gene activation, and how this priming affects gene expression after mitosis, remains elusive.  In the Drosophila embryo, the maternally provided Zelda pioneer factor is responsible for the awakening of the zygotic genome. In this preprint, the authors examine the enhancer expression dynamics of a Zelda responsive element, and the dynamic properties of Zelda in living Drosophila embryos, through two cycles of cell division. In particular, they measure the temporal coordination in Zelda activation through a synthetic regulatory element. The authors also test how the initial state of activity of the enhancer (memory) impacts on gene activation. By examining Zelda dynamics in living embryos during mitosis, they find that Zelda accelerates transcription and fosters synchrony but is not the basis for transcriptional mitotic memory.

Movie kindly provided by the authors showing the dynamics during various nuclear divisions of the snail shadow enhancer. MS2 transcription sites are in green (using MCP-GFP), and nuclei are labeled in red (using His2Av-RFP).


Why I chose the paper:

How gene regulation is precisely temporally controlled is one of the most interesting questions in developmental biology. One way to understand what’s going on is to characterize and study the dynamic activity of enhancers, and we need to find new ways to study how enhancers regulate gene expression.

This preprint offers a novel way to interpret enhancer dynamics through cell division and study transcriptional regulation by enhancers. The authors had previously shown how cells with memory activate transcription twice as fast as those with inactive mothers (1), but this time they focus on the role of Zelda in temporal coordination. I really like the fact that the authors are able to reproduce the activation kinetics of the endogenous shadow enhancer with their synthetic version that contains two Zelda binding sites. In addition, they implement an automated segmentation and tracking system that allows them to study hundreds of nuclei during multiple cell divisions. This system, once implemented, can save hours of tedious manual tracking, and provides a huge number of nuclei to analyse quantitatively. With this data, the authors move on to design a mathematical model to learn how memory could work. They model the time of reactivation after mitosis of cells with or without memory and find that inactive cells require at least three transitions to become active. The fitting to the model also shows that memory may be potentiated by reducing the number of steps required for post-mitotic transcriptional activation; something that couldn’t have been proposed without the model.

Unexpectedly, they find that Zelda does not play a role in setting the memory, since reducing Zelda levels leads to a reduction in activation kinetics but memory is still present. Neither does Zelda function as a mitotic bookmarking protein, since it is not retained on the chromosomes during mitosis. To pin down Zelda’s mode of action, the authors go one step further and perform fluorescent recovery after photo-bleaching and fluorescent correlation spectroscopy experiments. This thorough analysis of Zelda kinetic properties demonstrates that Zelda is highly dynamic and binds transiently to chromatin. The preprint concludes that Zelda accelerates the various transitions required prior to transcriptional activation.

How this work moves the field forward:

Regulatory sequences contain multiple transcription factor binding sites that are responsible for the spatio-temporal expression patterns of genes. We have long tried to decode the map to predict how the number, affinity and arrangement of sites determines transcription. This gets even more complicated if we consider that a single gene can respond to multiple enhancers, and these can exhibit overlapping spatiotemporal activity. This preprint advances our understanding of how enhancers coordinate gene expression, and emphasises how quantitative measurements coupled with mathematical modelling could provide precise and accurate models for transcription.

References :

  1. Transcriptional Memory in the Drosophila Embryo. Ferraro T, Esposito E, Mancini L, Ng S, Lucas T, Coppey M, Dostatni N, Walczak AM, Levine M, Lagha M. Curr Biol. 2016 Jan 25;26(2):212-8.
  2. Transcriptional precision and accuracy in development: from measurements to models and mechanisms. Bentovim L, Harden TT, DePace AH. Development. 2017 Nov 1;144(21):3855-3866.

Questions to the authors:

  1. In the model, there are two possible parameters that define the memory function, (1) the number of transitions between discrete transcriptional states and (2) the duration of each transition. Have the authors considered to describe/identify the three transitions and/or metastable states, and explore parameter ‘a’ further?
  2. I wonder if the authors could clarify further how the model supports their finding that the increase number of binding sites has an effect on the durations of the transitions and not on the number of states.

Tags: enhancer, fruit fly, gene expression, quantitative

Posted on: 9th April 2018

Read preprint (No Ratings Yet)

  • Author's response

    Mounia Lagha shared

    In this preprint, we studied the dynamics of enhancer expression during early Drosophila embryogenesis. In particular, we tried to understand the role of the pioneer factor Zelda on temporal control of gene expression using quantitative live imaging. Our three main findings are:

    1. Zelda is able to critically accelerate transcriptional initiation following mitosis, regardless of the past transcriptional status. Using mathematical modelling we propose that Zelda is able to accelerate transitions between discrete transcriptional states. (A detailed analysis and discussion of the mathematical model will be provided in an independent manuscript by O.Radulescu). This result raised one question: what could these discrete transcriptional states correspond to?Although purely speculative, we think these steps could correspond to chromatin opening, transcription factor binding, and to the assembly of the pre-initiation complex. Further investigations in that direction would be very interesting.
    2. Zelda is not required for mitotic memory. As a pioneer factor, Zelda was a good candidate for this mitotic memory. But surprisingly in the absence of Zelda, mitotic memory persists.
    3. In spite of its role in fostering a rapid transcriptional activation, we reveal that Zelda is highly dynamic, with transient chromatin binding and is evicted during mitosis.  We also found that Zelda is able to form local hubs within the nucleus. Similarly to what has been recently shown for Ubx (Crocker lab) and Bcd (Darzacq lab), we propose that Zelda local aggregation can compensate for its transient binding properties. Further investigations would be required to show if Zelda local accumulation could lead to a phase transition type of compartmentalization within the fly blastoderm nucleus.

    Answers to the questions:

    1. Indeed it would very exciting to further characterize what these various discrete transcriptional states could correspond to. We are currently trying to examine the effect of varying the concentrations of one activator (dorsal) to examine its effect on the ‘a’ parameter of our model. Future quantitative analysis of pre-initiation complex mutants in trans and minimal promoter mutants in cis should help clarifying the nature of these steps.
    2. The estimated a and b parameter of the model are provided for each genotype in Table 1. We did not demonstrate nor stated that Zld binding sites increase had solely an effect on the durations of the transitions. However we do indeed see that the main striking effect of adding extra Zelda binding sites is on the reduction in b parameter, in other words in the acceleration of transitions. Given what is known about Zelda, we speculate that by locally opening chromatin, Zelda binding creates a permissive environment, where jumping from one step to another would be faster.

    Have your say

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    Sign up to customise the site to your preferences and to receive alerts

    Register here

    Also in the developmental biology category:

    The cell wall regulates dynamics and size of plasma-membrane nanodomains in Arabidopsis.

    Joseph Franics McKenna, Daniel Rolfe, Stephen E D Webb, et al.

    Selected by Marc Somssich

    Psychiatric risk gene NT5C2 regulates protein translation in human neural progenitor cells

    Rodrigo R.R. Duarte, Nathaniel D. Bachtel, Marie-Caroline Cotel, et al.

    Selected by Joanna Cross

    A Scube2-Shh feedback loop links morphogen release to morphogen signaling to enable scale invariant patterning of the ventral neural tube

    Zach Collins, Kana Ishimatsu, Tony Tsai, et al.

    Selected by Teresa Rayon


    Epiblast formation by Tead-Yap-dependent expression of pluripotency factors and competitive elimination of unspecified cells

    Masakazu Hashimoto, Hiroshi Sasaki

    Selected by Sarah Bowling, Teresa Rayon

    Single cell transcriptomics reveals spatial and temporal dynamics of gene expression in the developing mouse spinal cord

    Julien Delile, Teresa Rayon, Manuela Melchionda, et al.

    Selected by Reena Lasrado


    The Toll pathway inhibits tissue growth and regulates cell fitness in an infection-dependent manner

    Federico Germani, Daniel Hain, Denise Sternlicht, et al.

    Selected by Rohan Khadilkar

    Rapid embryonic cell cycles defer the establishment of heterochromatin by Eggless/SetDB1 in Drosophila

    Charles A Seller, Chun-Yi Cho, Patrick H O'Farrell

    Selected by Gabriel Aughey

    A histidine kinase gene is required for large radius root tip circumnutation and surface exploration in rice

    Kevin R Lehner, Isaiah Taylor, Erin N McCaskey, et al.

    Selected by Martin Balcerowicz

    Actomyosin-driven tension at compartmental boundaries orients cell division independently of cell geometry in vivo

    Elena Scarpa, Cedric Finet, Guy Blanchard, et al.

    Selected by Ivana Viktorinová

    Molecular organization of integrin-based adhesion complexes in mouse Embryonic Stem Cells

    Shumin Xia, Evelyn K.F. Yim, Pakorn Kanchanawong


    Superresolution architecture of pluripotency guarding adhesions

    Aki Stubb, Camilo Guzmán, Elisa Närvä, et al.

    Selected by Nicola Stevenson, Amanda Haage

    Transcriptional initiation and mechanically driven self-propagation of a tissue contractile wave during axis elongation

    Anais Bailles, Claudio Collinet, Jean-Marc Philippe, et al.

    Selected by Sundar Naganathan


    Revealing the nanoscale morphology of the primary cilium using super-resolution fluorescence microscopy

    Joshua Yoon, Colin J. Comerci, Lucien E. Weiss, et al.

    Selected by Gautam Dey

    Signaling dynamics control cell fate in the early Drosophila embryo

    Heath E Johnson, Stanislav Y Shvartsman, Jared E Toettcher

    Selected by Yara E. Sánchez Corrales


    Three-dimensional tissue stiffness mapping in the mouse embryo supports durotaxis during early limb bud morphogenesis

    Min Zhu, Hirotaka Tao, Mohammad Samani, et al.

    Selected by Natalie Dye

    PUMILIO hyperactivity drives premature aging of Norad-deficient mice

    Florian Kopp, Mehmet Yalvac, Beibei Chen, et al.

    Selected by Carmen Adriaens

    Synergy with TGFβ ligands switches WNT pathway dynamics from transient to sustained during human pluripotent cell differentiation

    Joseph Massey, Yida Liu, Omar Alvarenga, et al.

    Selected by Pierre Osteil