Menu

Close

Memory sequencing reveals heritable single cell gene expression programs associated with distinct cellular behaviors

Sydney M Shaffer, Benjamin L Emert, Ann E. Sizemore, Rohit Gupte, Eduardo Torre, Danielle S Bassett, Arjun Raj

Preprint posted on July 27, 2018 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/early/2018/07/27/379016

Short-term memory: persistence of transient but heritable fluctuations in mRNA levels confer phenotypic variability to genetically identical cells

Selected by Leighton Daigh

Background

Cellular memory enables mother cells to pass on phenotypic information from mother cells from daughter cells in lifeforms from bacteria to multicellular organisms. Genomic DNA sequences represent the most stable form of cellular memory, allowing high fidelity transmission of memory over many generations. Epigenetic memory (e.g., inheritance of chromatin state) allows more plasticity while retaining some degree of stability. For example, epigenetic inheritance is important in development as cells differentiate and need to maintain memory of germ layer, tissue type, etc.

However, the authors note that more transient forms of cellular memory are less well studied and the subject of debate. While cell-to-cell variations in mRNA transcription have been observed, the importance and physiological relevance of these fluctuations is still unclear. Shaffer et al. therefore set out to determine if fluctuations in mRNA expression could be inherited over several rounds of cell division, and if they do, whether this would have phenotypic consequences.

Key findings

To identify transcripts that may exhibit fluctuations persisting over multiple generations of cell divisions, the authors combined Luria and Delbrück’s fluctuation analysis with bulk-cell mRNA sequencing, a technique they termed “MemorySeq.” An isogenic melanoma cell line was sorted into single-cell clones, and each clone was expanded to ~100,000 cells. Each clonal population was subjected to bulk-cell RNA sequencing. The authors looked for transcripts that exhibited a high degree of variance amongst the clonal populations. The authors describe the rational as follows: if a transcript has rapid fluctuations that don’t persist over generations, then during the expansion of each clone many cells will transition in and out of a “high” expression state (Figure 1). Thus, sequencing counts of a given transcript will be fairly similar across clonal populations. However, if a transcript exhibits slower, more persistent fluctuations, then “high” expression of this slowly fluctuating transcript will be inherited across cell divisions. If a cell happened to be in the “high” state early on following single-cell sorting, then clonal expansion will result in a disproportionally high level of that transcript in the population. A slowly-fluctuating transcript (i.e., one with short-term memory) is therefore one with high variability in transcript level across the different clonal populations. The authors were particularly interested in slowly fluctuating transcripts that might be stable across multiple cell divisions, allowing phenotypic inheritance.

Figure 1: Schematic explaining the experimental design for MemorySeq. Panels reproduced from Figure 1B of Shaffer et al., 2018 under a CC-BY-NC-ND 4.0.

 

Using this technique, the authors identify 227 slowly fluctuating transcripts (e.g., NGFR). The authors validate their findings through several orthogonal methods. Sparse plating followed by a growth period and mRNA FISH revealed colonies of high-expressing cells amongst a plate of otherwise low-expressing cells. The close spatial proximity of these cells suggests they were all derived from a single highly-expressing cell, providing additional evidence for persistence of high expression levels across multiple generations. The authors also performed endogenous tagging of the NGFR locus with a fluorescent protein. Timelapse fluorescence microscopy of the tagged NGFR protein revealed fluctuations in protein level, suggesting that fluctuations in transcript level translate to fluctuations in protein level.

The authors then provided a nice demonstration of phenotypic consequences of slow fluctuations in transcript level. Cells were sorted for those expressing high levels of the NGFR protein. NGFR-high cells or the original mixed population were treated with a MEK inhibitor, a drug used clinically for the treatment of melanoma. In the mixed population, few resistant colonies were observed. However, in the NGFR-high sorted cells, there was a much greater outgrowth of resistant colonies. Thus, slow fluctuations in transcripts like NGFR may be clinically important in the resistance of cancer cells to targeted therapies.

To demonstrate the flexibility of MemorySeq, the authors also use the technique on a triple-negative breast cancer cell line. Once again, they identify transcripts with slow fluctuations and show that these fluctuations may underlie chemotherapy resistance. This is a nice validation of the technique and suggests that it may be suitable for more widespread use in identifying potential resistance genes in a variety of cancer types and treatment modalities.

Why I picked this preprint

I particularly like this preprint for its readability. The language is clear and concise, with nice explanations of the concepts and interpretations of the data. Diagrams in the first panel of almost every figure clearly depict the experimental setup and hypotheses for potential outcomes of the experiment. Figures are simple to understand and can stand on their own. Overall, it makes for a fun reading experience where you get to follow along with an interesting scientific story.

A better understanding of more flexible forms of cellular memory will contribute to our understanding of how cancer cells may avoid therapy, as the authors demonstrate. Transient memory may also prove important in aspects of normal cellular functioning as well. For example, transient fluctuations in mRNA expression levels may be important during development or in response to environmental stressors such as viral infection. Therefore, I expect future studies to build on this interesting concept and extend it to other areas of cell and organismal biology.

I also enjoy the use of classical techniques combined with new methods to answer interesting questions in biology. In this paper (and in a past paper), the authors employed fluctuation analysis as the fundamental technique of the paper (Shaffer et al., 2017). This technique was most famously used in Luria and Delbrück’s seminal paper studying the heritable nature of bacterial resistance to bacteria-destroying viruses (Luria and Delbrück, 1943). The combination of modern and classical techniques makes for a fun paper that inspired a sense of nostalgia for me.

To those interested in reading more about classical biology, I would recommend The Eighth of Creation by Horace Judson and Phage and the Origins of Molecular Biology from Cold Spring Harbor Lab Press. Both books provide insight into the context behind many of the famous biology experiments of the 20th century.

Additional Questions

  • I think the most intriguing question from this work is: from where do the slow fluctuations arise? There are many steps in the generation of an RNA transcript, and I could imagine that any one (or more) of them could give rise to fluctuations in transcript level.
  • To what degree do fluctuations in transcript level correlate with fluctuations in protein level? Fluctuations in NGFR protein levels are demonstrated, but I’m curious to what degree this is more universally true.
  • Are these long-term changes in mRNA levels reversible? At what frequency do cells revert to/from the high-expression state?

Citations and Further reading

  • Luria, S. E., Delbrück, M. (1943). Mutations of Bacteria from Virus Sensitivity to Virus Resistance. Genetics 28​, 491–511.
  • Shaffer, S.M., Dunagin, M.C., Torborg, S.R., Torre, E.A., Emert, B., Krepler, C., Beqiri, M., Sproesser, K., Brafford, P.A., Xiao, M., et al. (2017). Rare cell variability and drug-induced reprogramming as a mode of cancer drug resistance. Nature 546, 431-435.
  • Symmons, O., and Raj, A. (2016). What’s Luck Got to Do with It: Single Cells, Multiple Fates, and Biological Nondeterminism. Mol Cell 62, 788-802.

Tags: melanoma, mrna sequencing, transcription

Posted on: 11th September 2018

Read preprint (1 votes)




  • 1 comment

    2 months

    Carmen Adriaens

    Hey Leighton, awesome preLight!

    This study pertains very interestingly to another concept in RNA/cell identity biology: are each of the cells inherently different from each other (do they have their own identity?) or are they the same and do they display differences in “behavior” (does their mood change upon their context?). Is this behavior, potentially driven by its environment, going to be ingrained in the next generation? This is particularly fascinating, thinking about how each cell descents from another one in the population (which, even in normal development, is true, to an extreme extent).

    As we are starting to understand how a single cell in a tissue distinguishes itself from its neighbor, and how it knows what to “do” in its exact location within a certain tissue, I think these concepts and questions are becoming increasingly important. Basic (in-plate) experiments may prove extremely useful to start studying, in a potentially slightly less complex model system (the plate, the monolayer), a concept that we will hopefully decipher in the future!




    2

    Have your say

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Sign up to customise the site to your preferences and to receive alerts

    Register here

    Also in the cancer biology category:

    Unjamming overcomes kinetic and proliferation arrest in terminally differentiated cells and promotes collective motility of carcinoma.

    Andrea Palamidessi, Chiara Malinverno, Emanuela FRITTOLI, et al.



    Selected by Tim Fessenden

    1

    STAT3 promotes melanoma metastasis by CEBP-induced repression of the MITF pigmentation pathway

    Alexander Swoboda, Robert Soukup, Katharina Kinslechner, et al.



    Selected by Hannah Brunsdon

    Anti-angiogenic effects of VEGF stimulation on endothelium deficient in phosphoinositide recycling

    Amber N Stratman, Olivia M Farrelly, Constantinos M Mikelis, et al.



    Selected by Coert Margadant

    Profiling the surface proteome identifies actionable biology for TSC1 mutant cells beyond mTORC1 signaling

    Junnian Wei, Kevin K. Leung, Charles Truillet, et al.



    Selected by Rob Hynds

    1

    Precise tuning of gene expression output levels in mammalian cells

    Yale S. Michaels, Mike B Barnkob, Hector Barbosa, et al.



    Selected by Tim Fessenden

    1

    Moving beyond P values: Everyday data analysis with estimation plots

    Joses Ho, Tayfun Tumkaya, Sameer Aryal, et al.



    Selected by Gautam Dey

    1

    JNK-mediated spindle reorientation in stem cells promotes dysplasia in the aging intestine

    Daniel Hu, Heinrich Jasper



    Selected by Maiko Kitaoka

    Mitotic chromosome alignment is required for proper nuclear envelope reassembly

    Cindy L Fonseca, Heidi LH Malaby, Leslie A Sepaniac, et al.



    Selected by Maiko Kitaoka

    SWI/SNF remains localized to chromatin in the presence of SCHLAP1

    Jesse R Raab, Keriayn N Smith, Camarie C Spear, et al.



    Selected by Carmen Adriaens

    1

    Single-cell Map of Diverse Immune Phenotypes Driven by the Tumor Microenvironment

    Elham Azizi, Ambrose J. Carr, George Plitas, et al.



    Selected by Tim Fessenden

    Cancer modeling by Transgene Electroporation in Adult Zebrafish (TEAZ)

    Scott J Callahan, Stephanie Tepan, Yan M Zhang, et al.



    Selected by Hannah Brunsdon

    1

    PDX Finder: A Portal for Patient-Derived tumor Xenograft Model Discovery

    Nathalie Conte, Jeremy Mason, Csaba Halmagyi, et al.



    Selected by Carmen Adriaens

    HIF1-alpha expressing cells induce a hypoxic-like response in neighbouring cancer cells

    Hannah Harrison, Henry J Pegg, Jamie Thompson, et al.



    Selected by Anh Hoang Le

    Long-term live imaging of the Drosophila adult midgut reveals real-time dynamics of cell division, differentiation, and loss

    Judy Martin, Erin Nicole Sanders, Paola Moreno-Roman, et al.



    Selected by Natalie Dye

    A role for RNA and DNA:RNA hybrids in the modulation of DNA repair by homologous recombination

    Giuseppina D'Alessandro, Marek Adamowicz, Donna Whelan, et al.



    Selected by Carmen Adriaens

    Nuclear envelope assembly defects link mitotic errors to chromothripsis

    Shiwei Liu, Mijung Kwon, Mark Mannino, et al.



    Selected by Gautam Dey

    Also in the cell biology category:

    Drosophila kinesin-8 stabilises kinetochore-microtubule interaction

    Tomoya Edzuka, Gohta Goshima



    Selected by Ben Craske, Thibault Legal and Toni McHugh

    1

    Unjamming overcomes kinetic and proliferation arrest in terminally differentiated cells and promotes collective motility of carcinoma.

    Andrea Palamidessi, Chiara Malinverno, Emanuela FRITTOLI, et al.



    Selected by Tim Fessenden

    1

    Tension on kinetochore substrates is insufficient to prevent Aurora-triggered detachment

    Anna K de Regt, Charles L Asbury, Sue Biggins



    Selected by Angika Basant

    1

    Single-cell RNA sequencing reveals novel cell differentiation dynamics during human airway epithelium regeneration

    Sandra Ruiz Garcia, Marie Deprez, Kevin Lebrigand, et al.



    Selected by Rob Hynds

    1

    Actomyosin-driven tension at compartmental boundaries orients cell division independently of cell geometry in vivo

    Elena Scarpa, Cedric Finet, Guy Blanchard, et al.



    Selected by Ivana Viktorinová

    Molecular organization of integrin-based adhesion complexes in mouse Embryonic Stem Cells

    Shumin Xia, Evelyn K.F. Yim, Pakorn Kanchanawong

    AND

    Superresolution architecture of pluripotency guarding adhesions

    Aki Stubb, Camilo Guzmán, Elisa Närvä, et al.



    Selected by Nicola Stevenson, Amanda Haage

    Transcriptional initiation and mechanically driven self-propagation of a tissue contractile wave during axis elongation

    Anais Bailles, Claudio Collinet, Jean-Marc Philippe, et al.



    Selected by Sundar Naganathan

    1

    Bridging the divide: bacteria synthesizing archaeal membrane lipids

    Laura Villanueva, F. A. Bastiaan von Meijenfeldt, Alexander B. Westbye, et al.

    AND

    Extensive transfer of membrane lipid biosynthetic genes between Archaea and Bacteria

    Gareth A. Coleman, Richard D. Pancost, Tom A. Williams



    Selected by Gautam Dey

    1

    Revealing the nanoscale morphology of the primary cilium using super-resolution fluorescence microscopy

    Joshua Yoon, Colin J. Comerci, Lucien E. Weiss, et al.



    Selected by Gautam Dey

    Signaling dynamics control cell fate in the early Drosophila embryo

    Heath E Johnson, Stanislav Y Shvartsman, Jared E Toettcher



    Selected by Yara E. Sánchez Corrales

    1

    Lysosome exocytosis is required for mitosis

    Charlotte Nugues, Nordine Helassa, Robert Burgoyne, et al.



    Selected by claudia conte

    Three-dimensional tissue stiffness mapping in the mouse embryo supports durotaxis during early limb bud morphogenesis

    Min Zhu, Hirotaka Tao, Mohammad Samani, et al.



    Selected by Natalie Dye

    PUMILIO hyperactivity drives premature aging of Norad-deficient mice

    Florian Kopp, Mehmet Yalvac, Beibei Chen, et al.



    Selected by Carmen Adriaens

    3D Tissue elongation via ECM stiffness-cued junctional remodeling

    Dong-Yuan Chen, Justin Crest, Sebastian J Streichan, et al.



    Selected by Sundar Naganathan

    Transient intracellular acidification regulates the core transcriptional heat shock response

    Catherine G Triandafillou, Christopher D Katanski, Aaron R Dinner, et al.



    Selected by Srivats Venkataramanan

    1

    Budding yeast complete DNA replication after chromosome segregation begins

    Tsvetomira Ivanova, Michael Maier, Alsu Missarova, et al.



    Selected by Gautam Dey, Maiko Kitaoka

    Also in the molecular biology category:

    Signaling dynamics control cell fate in the early Drosophila embryo

    Heath E Johnson, Stanislav Y Shvartsman, Jared E Toettcher



    Selected by Yara E. Sánchez Corrales

    1

    PUMILIO hyperactivity drives premature aging of Norad-deficient mice

    Florian Kopp, Mehmet Yalvac, Beibei Chen, et al.



    Selected by Carmen Adriaens

    Target-specific precision of CRISPR-mediated genome editing

    Anob M Chakrabarti, Tristan Henser-Brownhill, Josep Monserrat, et al.



    Selected by Rob Hynds

    1

    Transient intracellular acidification regulates the core transcriptional heat shock response

    Catherine G Triandafillou, Christopher D Katanski, Aaron R Dinner, et al.



    Selected by Srivats Venkataramanan

    1

    Memory sequencing reveals heritable single cell gene expression programs associated with distinct cellular behaviors

    Sydney M Shaffer, Benjamin L Emert, Ann E. Sizemore, et al.



    Selected by Leighton Daigh

    1

    Site-specific K63 ubiquitinomics reveals post-initiation regulation of ribosomes under oxidative stress

    Songhee Back, Christine Vogel, Gustavo M Silva



    Selected by Srivats Venkataramanan

    1

    Quantitative, real-time, single cell analysis in tissue reveals expression dynamics of neurogenesis

    Cerys S Manning, Veronica Biga, James Boyd, et al.



    Selected by Teresa Rayon

    The cis-regulatory logic underlying abdominal Hox-mediated repression versus activation of regulatory elements in Drosophila

    Arya Zandvakili, Juli Uhl, Ian Campbell, et al.



    Selected by Clarice Hong

    1

    Moving beyond P values: Everyday data analysis with estimation plots

    Joses Ho, Tayfun Tumkaya, Sameer Aryal, et al.



    Selected by Gautam Dey

    1

    A limited number of double-strand DNA breaks are sufficient to delay cell cycle progression.

    Jeroen van den Berg, Anna G. Manjon, Karoline Kielbassa, et al.



    Selected by Leighton Daigh

    Template switching causes artificial junction formation and false identification of circular RNAs

    Chong Tang, Tian Yu, Yeming Xie, et al.



    Selected by Fabio Liberante

    Dynamics and interactions of ADP/ATP transporter AAC3 in DPC detergent are not functionally relevant

    Vilius Kurauskas, Audrey Hessel, François Dehez, et al.

    AND

    Major concerns with the integrity of the mitochondrial ADP/ATP carrier in dodecyl-phosphocholine used for solution NMR studies

    Martin S. King, Paul G. Crichton, Jonathan J. Ruprecht, et al.



    Selected by Reid Alderson

    1

    Targeting light-gated chloride channels to neuronal somatodendritic domain reduces their excitatory effect in the axon

    Jessica Messier, Hongmei Chen, Zhao-Lin Cai, et al.

    AND

    High-efficiency optogenetic silencing with soma-targeted anion-conducting channelrhodopsins

    Mathias Mahn, Lihi Gibor, Katayun Cohen-Kashi Malina, et al.



    Selected by Mahesh Karnani

    2

    Glutamic acid is a carrier for hydrazine during the biosyntheses of fosfazinomycin and kinamycin

    Kwo-Kwang Abraham Wang, Tai L. Ng, Peng Wang, et al.



    Selected by Ellis O'Neill

    The Histone H3-H4 Tetramer is a Copper Reductase Enzyme

    Narsis Attar, Oscar A Campos, Maria Vogelauer, et al.



    Selected by Lauren Neves

    Super-Mendelian inheritance mediated by CRISPR/Cas9 in the female mouse germline

    Hannah A. Grunwald, Valentino M. Gantz, Gunnar Poplawski, et al.



    Selected by Rebekah Tillotson

    1

    Close