In response to Li et al.: Linker histones function in Drosophila embryogenesis

Albert Carbonell, Lazslo Henn, Juan Pérez-Roldán, Srividya Tamirisa, Anikó Szabó, Imre M. Boros, Fernando Azorín

Posted on: 29 September 2020

Preprint posted on 24 March 2020

When your results are challenged, revise and report the updated findings.

Selected by Sree Rama Chaitanya

Categories: cell biology, developmental biology, genetics, molecular biology

Context

Homodimers of four histones (H2A, H2A, H3, H4) form an octamer protein complex to wrap ~146bp DNA to form the building blocks of chromatin – nucleosome. Transcription, replication, and histone post-translational modifications (referred to as ‘histone code’) maintain a two-way relation to orchestrate the genome function. However, an underappreciated linker histone H1 binds at the DNA exit/entry gate of the nucleosome to facilitate high-order chromatin structure in turn to regulate a plethora of gene regulatory processes¹. The presence of multiple somatic and germline-specific H1 variants in metazoans, make it challenging to study H1 biology. But thanks to Drosophila, that harbors a single somatic H1 variant (dH1) and a single germline-specific H1 variant (dBigH1), promising as a tractable organism to unravel the complete biology of H1².

In the previous work³, the host lab identified the germline-specific dBigH1 in the Drosophila embryos that regulate zygotic-genome activation (ZGA); dBigH1 is eventually replaced by somatic dH1 at the onset of cellularization. Moreover, they also demonstrated loss-of-function dBigH1 mutation (bigH1¹⁰⁰) exhibits a higher lethality rate during embryogenesis. But challenging this finding, another group posted a preprint (Li et al. 2019) reporting that complete loss of dBigH1 does not induce embryonic lethality, with dH1 compensating the loss⁴. Therefore, the host lab of the initial study³ set forward to investigate this further and revisit their earlier findings.

Key outcomes

In the current preprint, the authors generated two null dbigH1 alleles – bigH1^NULL and bigH1^STOP – using CRISPR. In bigH1^NULL, the complete coding sequence is replaced by mCherry, and in bigH1^NSTOP, a stop codon was introduced at the N-terminal domain. dBigH1 was not detectable in ovaries and early embryos in either of these mutants. Intriguingly, they did not observe a significant effect on the embryo viability, supporting the claims in the Li’s preprint⁴. Not just that, the somatic dH1 levels were augmented in homozygous bigH1^NULL and bigH1^NSTOP mutants, but not in their earlier mutant bigH1¹⁰⁰ carrying flies³ (Fig. 1). They suggest that a lack of compensatory dH1 takeover could be the cause of incomplete loss of dBigH1 in bigH1¹⁰⁰ mutant flies. The authors’ further reasoned that acquired secondary mutations could have contributed to embryonic lethality in bigH1¹⁰⁰ flies.

The current preprint took a positive approach to unravel the discrepancies in results raised by another group. All in all – this is a great reminder to revisit and challenge our findings and importantly report the revised results to the scientific community.

Fig. 1: Compensatory dH1 expression. A) Immunofluorescence staining with a dH1 antibodies (in green) of wild-type Drosophila embryos at the cellular blastoderm stage (left) and before nc 7 (right). As in (A), embryos collected from *bigH1100/TM6B* parents (B), homozygous *bigH1NSTOP* parents (C), and homozygous *bigH1NULL* parents (D). DNA was stained with DAPI (in red). Insets show enlarged images. Taken directly from Fig. 2 of Carbonell A et. al., 2020 under a CC-BY 4.0 international license.

Acknowledgments

I am grateful to all the authors for their support, especially Dr. Fernando Azorin for being open to discuss the unpublished results and replying promptly.

References:

Tags: drosophila, linker histone h1, zga

doi: https://doi.org/10.1242/prelights.24984

Read preprint

(No Ratings Yet)

Author's response

Dr Fernando Azorin (FA) shared

1) Your work is laudable and inspiring to any scientist on how to take criticism positively and set forth an example to report revised findings, however small it may be. Do you have any comments? It will be interesting to hear your side of the story.

FA: Certainly, we were intrigued by the findings reported by Li and collaborators from Yikang S Rong’s lab⁴. However, to some extent, their findings were not unexpected since, in late 2018, Laszlo Henn from Imre Boros’ lab in Szeged shared with us some very interesting observations, which have been recently published⁵. Laszlo generated CRISPR/CAS9 lines in which the CDS of dBigH1 was replaced by that of somatic dH1. These lines, though showing some embryo defects, were viable. At that point, it became clear that somatic dH1 was largely rescuing dBigH1 loss-of-function (LOF), raising some doubts on the actual dBigH1 function in embryogenesis. Thus, we started a collaboration to address these questions and, as a first step, we decided to generate new dBigH1 LOF alleles by CRISPR/CAS9. We were in the middle of that when Li’s report came out. From this point of view, Li’s work⁴ was very enlightening and we were happy to reproduce their results with our newly generated LOF alleles. Thanks to the work from Yikang S. Rong’s lab, we could revise our previous conclusions and, overall, we now feel closer to understand dBigH1 function and regulation in embryogenesis. This story is an important reminder of how complex in vivo gene function studies can be, showing the caveats of using technologies as P-element excision to generate mutant conditions. Even when using CRISPR/Cas9 technology, we must be open to recheck our conclusions at any time since this technology does not seem to be as ‘clean’ as anticipated⁶. The continuous revision of previous models and conclusions is central to our work as scientists.

2) Now that you report this preprint. How are you planning to mitigate this challenge and take it forward?

FA: Currently, we are trying to understand the nature of the strong embryo lethality associated with the bigH1¹⁰⁰ allele, something that, we must say, is not being an easy task. In fact, in our initial work³, bigH1¹⁰⁰ lethality was significantly rescued by the zygotic expression of an ectopic UAS-dBigH1 construct. According to our current results, it appears that bigH1¹⁰⁰ lethality is the consequence of a complex interaction between maternal and zygotic defects. Once these studies are finished, we plan on submitting an extended version of this preprint describing in detail all these observations and discussing the best available tools to study the dBigH1 function. On the other hand, this challenge has opened new and very interesting questions. Unraveling the mechanisms underlying compensatory dH1 expression in dBigH1 LOF backgrounds is one of our main interests.

Have your say Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Sign up to customise the site to your preferences and to receive alerts

Also in the cell biology category:

Motor Clustering Enhances Kinesin-driven Vesicle Transport

Rui Jiang, Qingzhou Feng, Daguan Nong, et al.

Selected by 16 November 2024

Sharvari Pitke

Cellular signalling protrusions enable dynamic distant contacts in spinal cord neurogenesis

Joshua Hawley, Robert Lea, Veronica Biga, et al.

Selected by 15 November 2024

Ankita Walvekar

Green synthesized silver nanoparticles from Moringa: Potential for preventative treatment of SARS-CoV-2 contaminated water

Adebayo J. Bello, Omorilewa B. Ebunoluwa, Rukayat O. Ayorinde, et al.

Selected by 14 November 2024

Safieh Shah, Benjamin Dominik Maier

Discussion

Also in the developmental biology category:

Cellular signalling protrusions enable dynamic distant contacts in spinal cord neurogenesis

Joshua Hawley, Robert Lea, Veronica Biga, et al.

Selected by 15 November 2024

Ankita Walvekar

Actin-based deformations of the nucleus control multiciliated ependymal cell differentiation

Marianne Basso, Alexia Mahuzier, Syed Kaabir Ali, et al.

Selected by 30 October 2024

Ryan Harrison

HIF1A contributes to the survival of aneuploid and mosaic pre-implantation embryos

Estefania Sanchez-Vasquez, Marianne E. Bronner, Magdalena Zernicka-Goetz

Selected by 11 October 2024

Anchel De Jaime Soguero

Also in the genetics category:

Intracellular diffusion in the cytoplasm increases with cell size in fission yeast

Catherine Tan, Michael C. Lanz, Matthew Swaffer, et al.

Selected by 18 October 2024

Leeba Ann Chacko, Sameer Thukral

Discussion

Significantly reduced, but balanced, rates of mitochondrial fission and fusion are sufficient to maintain the integrity of yeast mitochondrial DNA

Brett T. Wisniewski, Laura L. Lackner

Selected by 30 August 2024

Leeba Ann Chacko

Discussion

The bat Influenza A virus subtype H18N11 induces nanoscale MHCII clustering upon host cell attachment

Maria Kaukab Osman, Jonathan Robert, Lukas Broich, et al.

Selected by 20 August 2024

Mitchell Sarmie, Mohammed A. Jalloh

Discussion

Also in the molecular biology category:

Green synthesized silver nanoparticles from Moringa: Potential for preventative treatment of SARS-CoV-2 contaminated water

Adebayo J. Bello, Omorilewa B. Ebunoluwa, Rukayat O. Ayorinde, et al.

Selected by 14 November 2024

Safieh Shah, Benjamin Dominik Maier

Discussion

Non-disruptive inducible labeling of ER-membrane contact sites using the Lamin B Receptor

Laura Downie, Nuria Ferrandiz, Megan Jones, et al.

Selected by 15 October 2024

Jonathan Townson

HIF1A contributes to the survival of aneuploid and mosaic pre-implantation embryos

Estefania Sanchez-Vasquez, Marianne E. Bronner, Magdalena Zernicka-Goetz

Selected by 11 October 2024

Anchel De Jaime Soguero

preLists in the cell biology category:

November in preprints – the CellBio edition

This is the first community-driven preList! A group of preLighters, with expertise in different areas of cell biology, have worked together to create this preprint reading lists for researchers with an interest in cell biology. Categories include: 1) cancer cell biology 2) cell cycle and division 3) cell migration and cytoskeleton 4) cell organelles and organisation 5) cell signalling and mechanosensing 6) genetics/gene expression

In response to Li et al.: Linker histones function in Drosophila embryogenesis

Context

Key outcomes

Acknowledgments

References:

Share this:

Have your say Cancel reply

Sign up to customise the site to your preferences and to receive alerts

Also in the cell biology category:

Motor Clustering Enhances Kinesin-driven Vesicle Transport

Cellular signalling protrusions enable dynamic distant contacts in spinal cord neurogenesis

Green synthesized silver nanoparticles from Moringa: Potential for preventative treatment of SARS-CoV-2 contaminated water

Also in the developmental biology category:

Cellular signalling protrusions enable dynamic distant contacts in spinal cord neurogenesis

Actin-based deformations of the nucleus control multiciliated ependymal cell differentiation

HIF1A contributes to the survival of aneuploid and mosaic pre-implantation embryos

Also in the genetics category:

Intracellular diffusion in the cytoplasm increases with cell size in fission yeast

Significantly reduced, but balanced, rates of mitochondrial fission and fusion are sufficient to maintain the integrity of yeast mitochondrial DNA

The bat Influenza A virus subtype H18N11 induces nanoscale MHCII clustering upon host cell attachment

Also in the molecular biology category:

Green synthesized silver nanoparticles from Moringa: Potential for preventative treatment of SARS-CoV-2 contaminated water

Non-disruptive inducible labeling of ER-membrane contact sites using the Lamin B Receptor

HIF1A contributes to the survival of aneuploid and mosaic pre-implantation embryos

preLists in the cell biology category:

November in preprints – the CellBio edition

BSCB-Biochemical Society 2024 Cell Migration meeting

‘In preprints’ from Development 2022-2023

preLights peer support – preprints of interest

The Society for Developmental Biology 82nd Annual Meeting

CSHL 87th Symposium: Stem Cells

Journal of Cell Science meeting ‘Imaging Cell Dynamics’

9th International Symposium on the Biology of Vertebrate Sex Determination

Alumni picks – preLights 5th Birthday

CellBio 2022 – An ASCB/EMBO Meeting

Fibroblasts

EMBL Synthetic Morphogenesis: From Gene Circuits to Tissue Architecture (2021)

FENS 2020

Planar Cell Polarity – PCP

BioMalPar XVI: Biology and Pathology of the Malaria Parasite

Cell Polarity

TAGC 2020

3D Gastruloids

ECFG15 – Fungal biology

ASCB EMBO Annual Meeting 2019

EMBL Seeing is Believing – Imaging the Molecular Processes of Life

Autophagy

Lung Disease and Regeneration

Cellular metabolism

BSCB/BSDB Annual Meeting 2019

MitoList

Biophysical Society Annual Meeting 2019

ASCB/EMBO Annual Meeting 2018

Also in the developmental biology category:

BSDB/GenSoc Spring Meeting 2024

GfE/ DSDB meeting 2024

‘In preprints’ from Development 2022-2023

preLights peer support – preprints of interest

The Society for Developmental Biology 82nd Annual Meeting

CSHL 87th Symposium: Stem Cells

Journal of Cell Science meeting ‘Imaging Cell Dynamics’

9th International Symposium on the Biology of Vertebrate Sex Determination

Alumni picks – preLights 5th Birthday

CellBio 2022 – An ASCB/EMBO Meeting

2nd Conference of the Visegrád Group Society for Developmental Biology

Fibroblasts

EMBL Synthetic Morphogenesis: From Gene Circuits to Tissue Architecture (2021)

EMBL Conference: From functional genomics to systems biology

Single Cell Biology 2020

Society for Developmental Biology 79th Annual Meeting

FENS 2020

Planar Cell Polarity – PCP

Cell Polarity

TAGC 2020

3D Gastruloids

ASCB EMBO Annual Meeting 2019

EDBC Alicante 2019

EMBL Seeing is Believing – Imaging the Molecular Processes of Life

SDB 78th Annual Meeting 2019

Lung Disease and Regeneration